An argument in favor of cloning and organ donation in the united states

The cloning of Dolly the sheep cost over 5 million dollars alone. It is autonomy "over" God, not autonomy "under" God.

The Rising Prospect of Human Cloning It was no longer ago than when the president of the United States first challenged the nation and charged his National Bioethics Advisory Commission 2 to give careful thought to how the United States should proceed regarding human cloning.

Conveying such a message, these authors say, could have harmful consequences for a multicultural society. They contain short segments of DNA. We know this, among others, from studying monozygotic twins. Somehow, even the dead donor seems to be donating as one last act, one final giving of what he still has to give, before the final silence.

New Zealand[ edit ] Altruism New Zealand law allows live donors to participate in altruistic organ donation only. Finally, some have pointed out that it is not clear whether cloning research is necessarily more labor intensive than experiments on cells and tissues now done in animals.

Many states have sought to encourage the donations to be made by allowing the consent to be noted on the driver's license. The future rights to one's organs would likely command a far lower market price, since most people do not die in such a way that organ retrieval is actually possible.

It may also benefit families indirectly, as the families of unsuitable donors are not approached to discuss organ donation. But during the experimental phase in particular, identifying the parents of clones produced in a laboratory may be even more troublesome.

Her argument was that the actual exploitation is an ethical failing, a human exploitation; a perception of the poor as organ sources which may be used to extend the lives of the wealthy. Further, the use of cloning to produce organs with a genotype identical to the recipient is a controversial topic, especially considering the possibility for an entire person to be brought into being for the express purpose of being destroyed for organ procurement.

This would not necessarily be the case were cloning to be implemented now Agar ; Buchanan Utility justifications are common in discussions of human cloning. Transplantation of discordant xenografts: It is also what is problematic about producing clones to provide spare parts, such as vital transplantable organs for other people.

Breakthrough in human cloning offers new transplant hope

Some might even question the sanity of people tempted to be lethal organ donors and wonder how truly "free" such a decision could ever be. Introducing money into such situations would likely aggravate this disruption: So even if a clone has a unique identity, she may experience more difficulties in establishing her identity than if she had not been a clone.

If the genetic material and egg are simply donated anonymously for experimental purposes, does the scientist who manipulates them and produces a child from them become the parent.

Therapeutic Cloning

Unless or until this success rate can be improved, it makes the widespread use of embryonic stems cells for medical purposes unlikely. An organ transplant and follow-up care can cost the prison system up to one million dollars.

What Dolly demonstrated was that it is possible to take a differentiated cell, turn back its biological clock, and make the cell behave as though it was a recently fertilized egg. Organ donation and transplantation save over 28, lives a year.

Get the facts, learn how it works, and what can be donated. What Can Be Donated. Organs; Corneas States with the highest percentage of registered donors (): Montana (89% of the population is registered) Alaska (86%).

Although the National Organ Transplant Act made it illegal to buy or sell organs in the United States inand the World Health Organization recommended a similar ban in (that was reaffirmed in ), support for a kidney market has blossomed in the past decade [17–23].

In this article, I argue that the market is not an ethical solution to the organ shortage. Human cloning has been used to create stem cells for adults for the first time in a breakthrough which could lead to tissue and organs being regrown.

Using the cloning technique which produced Dolly the sheep inresearchers were able for the first time to turn adult human skin cells into stem cells, which can grow into any type of tissue in the body.


The greater limitation to using embryonic stem cells (or stem cells generated by nuclear cloning) is that while those cells can be grown into differentiated cells and tissues, no means are known by which those cells can be coaxed to form organs outside of the embryo.

Therapeutic cloning can help create vital organs. This would be helpful for people suffering from kidney and other disorders, who are forced to wait years for a replacement organ.

Organ Donation Blog

Politicians do not consider the pros of therapeutic cloning and how it can be helpful to the citizens of their country. the United Kingdom, the United States.

"Presumed consent" in regard to organ procurement would mean the presumption on the part of society that unless someone has executed a document to the contrary, he/she would be considered to be "opting in" participation in organ donation.

An argument in favor of cloning and organ donation in the united states
Rated 5/5 based on 60 review